Billboard displaying orange Vanilla Coke advertisement header.

Sentiment analysis: the world may not want an Orange Vanilla Coke

Mission accomplished Coca-Cola. Every American basketball fan is now definitely aware of your new Orange Vanilla flavor. But whether or not they’ll buy it may be another matter entirely.

As one of the most visible advertisers at the NCAA’s March Madness tournament, Coca-Cola launched an Orange Vanilla Coke-themed takeover of game coverage, blitzing viewers with ads and promotions across TV, social, digital, outdoor, mobile, radio and experiential (there were even Orange Vanilla Coke tasting stations at the Minneapolis airport to greet tournament-goers). We dug into data from our Brandwatch social listening tool to analyze how the campaign impacted product awareness and sentiment over the course of the tournament. Here’s what we found:

1. The ads definitely helped lift awareness of the new flavor

The good news for Coca-Cola: consistent, sustained exposure to these ads did have an impact on the number of people talking about it. Over 15,000 unique authors mentioned “Orange Vanilla Coke” on channels like Twitter, Instagram, and Facebook during March Madness, a 131% increase in mentions over the previous period.

orange vanilla coke

orange vanilla coke

Looking at the top hashtags, most of these mentions were found in close proximity to content about #MarchMadness.

trending hashtags orange vanilla coke

In addition to its branded TV commercials and activations, much of this buzz was in large part thanks to both organic and sponsored influencer posts about the product. Everyone from Simone Biles to CBS reporters were adding to the conversation.

simone byles coke march madness ad


2. Overall, public reaction to the campaign was more negative than positive.

Now for the bad news. Our sentiment analysis of the 16,000 mentions shows that negative responses outweighed positive ones by nearly 3X. Yikes.

sentiment analysis

Negative reactions were centered around two main gripes. The first was disgust over the idea of, and in some cases, the actual taste of the Orange Vanilla flavor. If you haven’t tried it for yourself, let’s just say there were a lot of comparisons to baby aspirin, and the green barf emoji was used repeatedly.

The second was a growing anger over how many times the ads had been shown during commercial breaks. After three weeks of consistent coverage, negative sentiment spiked during the National Championship game, when we started seeing more people using words like “annoying,” “commercials” and “stop.”

orange vanilla coke sentiment

While Coca-Cola seemed to have covered its bases getting real spokespeople on board promoting the product online, there were still some important influencers for the March Madness audience who weren’t on board. A huge spike in mentions occurred on March 23 when this Barstool reporter put his foot down and said what everyone was thinking:

barstool reporter tweet

3. All this speculation likely drove people to try the product for themselves

Even if “disgust” was the most pronounced emotional reaction from the broader public, the second highest reaction—”surprise”—could be seen as a win. As part of Coca-Cola’s first new flavor launch in over a decade, a playful element of surprise was central to the campaign. “Crash,” the main TV spot, depicts a crossing guard initially shocked by a high-speed truck crash of flavors and Coke, but who then savors the can of Orange Vanilla Coke that rolls to her feet. The closing voiceover states, “Yeah, you heard that right.”

reactions to coke

Digging into the “surprise” category of data suggests that the campaign succeeded in reaching its target audience: variety seekers. Thousands of individuals who gave the beverage a try after seeing the campaign took to Twitter to share their real-time reactions.

orange vanilla coke surprise

Although the overall volume of negative sentiment surrounding this campaign makes me cringe, I’d argue this March Madness takeover was more effective at driving awareness and consumer trial than a single 30-second Superbowl commercial may have been.

How did you measure the success of your most recent marketing campaign? Was it all about leads and sales, or did you put your ear to the ground and measure the real-time impact of (and response to) your brand’s message?


Related Articles

The indispensable EVP
The arrival of the COVID-19 pandemic in early 2020 changed our working lives in an immediate, visceral way. Offices went vacant, plants slowly dying and forgotten lunches decaying in fridges. Employees adopted an entirely new…
Read More
How the current social climate is impacting color trends in design
As designers, we are taught that our color recommendations and choices influence our client audiences, their interactions with interfaces, how brands resonate with individuals, stand out from their competitors, and more. Color consulting is a…
Read More
Inclusive design considerations
At Grafik we have always been committed to having inclusive representation in our creative. But after witnessing the horrific murders of Black men and women at the hands of police and the subsequent Black Lives…
Read More
The explainer video, explained
If you’re looking for an easily digestible way to communicate what your company does, consider producing an explainer video. Instead of trying to describe your company’s process or services with plain text, an explainer video…
Read More