Mila Arrisueno and 2 former Grafik Employees working hard together

If you aren’t being challenged, you’re with the wrong agency

Think about your current branding/marketing agency. If you were to describe them, what words come to mind? Helpful, consistent, responsive, supportive?

These words aren’t uncommon, and in fact should be a requirement. With so much competition in the marketplace, if you aren’t currently with an agency you can rely on, you have dozens of other agencies to turn to.

But when you think about your agency, does the word “challenging” come to mind, too? Challenging in the way that a manager may push you to try something new that you’ve never thought of before.

Your agency must challenge you in that same way.

Take these two scenarios:

Scenario 1: Pleasing-focused agency

Your agency: “How has your most recent campaign been going? Anything that needs to be update or changed? We’re here to help with whatever you need!”

You: “Nothing really comes to mind at the moment that we need help with. We are loving the campaign!”


Scenario 2: Challenge-focused agency

Your agency: “I noticed in your Google Analytics that your bounce rate has drastically increased over the past few months since the campaign was launched, almost 5% higher than the average in your industry. Have you given any thought to a personalized landing page for each audience?”

You: “I didn’t even realize that the bounce rate was an issue. What is the average for our industry? And what could that personalized message potentially be?”

Which scenario would benefit your company more? (And are you currently going to your Google Analytics right now to check out your bounce rate?)

Ask yourself these three questions about your current branding/marketing agency. If you answer “no” to any of these questions, it may be time to rethink that relationship.

  1. Does your agency strive to continue learning about your industry? Sending you relevant news articles for discussions or inspiration?
  2. Do they seek to learn about your business as a whole, not just the scope of work they have been given? For example, are they proactively visiting your sales center? Speaking with employees to gather different perceptions? Reviewing Google Analytics data to raise any red flags you may be missing?
  3. Do they approach you with unique insights, ideas, or questions that had yet to cross your mind? Are they starting a conversation you would never have had without them, presenting a new way to potentially save you time, money, or even a headache?

If you aren’t being challenged by your agency to think differently, then why would you want to keep them?

You’d be surprised how quickly your conversations will turn from routine check-ins to true collaborative working sessions when you work with an agency who challenges you.

Grafik logo as a placeholder for author's image
Amanda Brooks

Related Articles

What to expect when you’re rebranding
I’ve heard more than one CMO over the years jokingly refer to his or her corporate rebrand project as, “my baby.” And with good reason: like the lead-up to becoming a proud new parent, these…
Read More
New year, new initiatives, new RFPs
It’s that time of the year when budgets renew, priorities change, and organizations refocus. And with big goals looming large ahead, you may be looking for an outside creative partner to help deliver expertise, guidance,…
Read More
Rethinking your donor engagement strategy? Start here.
As summer comes to a close, we’ve rounded up the hottest nonprofit sector stories, data, and trends to help take your fall fundraising efforts to new heights. 1. Not just for retail: The surge in…
Read More
How Nonprofits Can Beat the “Summer Slump”
While many nonprofits struggle to engage donors during the summer months, it’s a great time to take stock in your organization’s communications strategy and start charting a course for the months ahead. Here are a…
Read More